Back to Silas S. Brown's home page
Sound-recorder apps on Android OSStudents recording lectures etc have generally moved from dedicated hardware to mobile 'apps'. Below are my notes comparing some of the available alternatives on the Android platform. Usual disclaimers apply.
I only list apps that:
- Work in the background and/or with screen off (saving battery),
- can record a talk even in the unpaid version of the app.
- StereoMatch "Amazing MP3 Recorder"
- Works with screen readers
- Large controls, easy to operate (problems with early versions have been fixed)
- Visual indication of microphone pick-up on the left of the screen
- Closed source (although currently without advertisements apart from suggestions to upgrade to Pro)
- If you don't like reading about voice changers and what people do with them, you might not appreciate all the "what's new" updates
- Onall Sound Recorder No Ads (removed from "Play Store" in March 2019)
- Unpaid version can record to MP3, which might be useful if you need to share the recording with someone who can't play OGG and you can't first get to a desktop to recode it (although recoding might still be a good idea for speech, as when set to 44.1k it seems to approximate lame's --abr 80 setting)
- Decibel readout during recording (might be useful for making noise complaints?)
- Closed source
- Small controls
- Switching off the screen during recording results in the app being backgrounded, which makes pause/stop take longer later
- Triveous Voice Recorder
- Visual indicator of microphone pick-up
- Closed source
- Poor use of storage space. Although Triveous can compress to AAC (or M4A in version 5; 128 kbps = 55M/hr, convertible via mplayer -ao pcm:file=output.wav or some installations of Audacity), it also makes an uncompressed WAV of the current track while encoding, so you need to allow space for this and/or keep each track short,
- and the old Version 3 even fails to delete them (for tracks exceeding about 18 minutes depending on hardware)---this was fixed in Version 4, but the device still needs space for the WAV of each track while recording that track, regardless of the "realtime" setting (non-realtime results in an extra encoding step taking about 50% of the recording time).
- If you do have space for WAV (3.3hr/G) then for distant sources it's (usually) better to just use WAV and re-code it later, but this is no longer an option in version 5 which is M4A-only (but still has the "need to leave room for the WAV as well" limitation that StereoMatch doesn't have).
- Triveous also requires Android 4.4 or above, so won't work on old 4.1 phones like the Galaxy S2
- Rehearsal Assistant (removed from "Play Store" in December 2017)
- Serious bug when recording uncompressed (see its SourceForge Bug 4)---on some devices, if you do too much in other apps such as the browser, background recording can be aborted without clearing the red indicator on the notification bar, leaving an incomplete wav file that needs sox --ignore-length to play.
- For nearby sounds you could try the 48 kbps AMR-NB .3gp (loadable in Audacity, mplayer etc) but the quality is lower.
iPhone ships with Voice Memos (possibly under Extras); this too works with the display switched off or in the background, and records 64kbit AAC (.m4a). Some other iOS programs output
.aif files that might need converting on a Mac.
All material © Silas S. Brown unless otherwise stated.
Android is a trademark of Google LLC.
iPhone is a trademark of Apple in some countries.
Mac is a trademark of Apple Inc.
MP3 is a trademark that was registered in Europe to Hypermedia GmbH Webcasting but I was unable to confirm its current holder.
SourceForge is a trademark of VA Software Corporation.
Any other trademarks I mentioned without realising are trademarks of their respective holders.